When you say NANOPARTICLES of elemental atoms contained in original drug substances are the ACTIVE PRINCIPLES of homeopathic potentized drugs, first of all you are bound to explain where from this unending supply of original substances come in even in minutest doses of preparations diluted much above avogadro limit or 12c, whereas it is well known to everybody that number of molecules in a sample of substance will be limited by avogadro number.
Remember, what the scientists of IIT-B said was only that they could “detect nanoparticles of elemental particles floating randomly in the 1% top layer of the solution”!
You are bound to explain how these “random particles” found to be floating on “top 1% layer” of solution could be the active principles of each and every drops and split drops of even the “bottom most layer” of drugs used by homeopaths!
Will you theorize using your “quantum science” that unlimited number of elemental particles are generated by the process of serial dilution and shaking involved in potentization?
When you say NANOPARTICLES of elemental atoms contained in original drug substances are the ACTIVE PRINCIPLES of homeopathic potentized drugs, you are bound to explain by what mechanism the complex chemical molecules contained in drug substances are converted into nanoparticles or “clusters of elemental atoms” by the simple process of serial dilution involved in the process of homeopathic potentization.
Do you think the strong co-valent bonds that hold atoms together in complex chemical molecules could be broken and atoms liberated by the simple mechanical energy applied during shaking or succussion? If so, can anybody be so ridiculous to imagine to split the simple water molecules into hydrogen and oxygen by shaking water taken in a bottle?
When you say NANOPARTICLES of elemental atoms you claim to have detected in some highly diluted samples subjected to spectroscopic studies are the ACTIVE PRINCIPLES of homeopathic potentized drugs, you are bound to explain how these simple elemental particles or their clusters can represent or reproduce the biological and medicinal properties of highly complex biological molecules such as proteins, enzymes, alkaloids, glycosides, cytokines, hormones, biological ligands, metabolites etc etc contained in the drug substances used to prepare potentized homeopathic drugs.
For example, the highly neurotoxic alkaloid STRYCHNINE contained in nux vomica is a chemical molecule with formula C21H22N2O2. BRUCINE is another alkaloid with chemical formula C23H26N2O4, and with different set of chemical and biological properties . Both of them contain only carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen and oxygen, but in different numbers. Do you think these individual elemental atoms generated by division of strychnine can produce the neurotoxic biological effects of strychnine?
Do you think the individual hydrogen and oxygen atoms produced by division of water molecule can produce the chemical or biological properties of water?
Please understand, it is not merely the individual constituent elemental atoms that produce the biological properties of a chemical molecule, but their peculiar organization, spacial placement of atoms, energy levels, molecular conformation and a lot of other factors are involved in it.
It is utter foolishness to think that individual elemental particles or their clusters isolated from complex chemical molecules can represent or produce their highly complex biological or medicinal effects.
Please be careful not to forget these simple basic things while theorizing that nanoparticles of elemental atoms are the active principles of potentized homeopathic drugs.